hahahah, i guess the good point about this blog is that i can rant graphic related stuff without being noticed? xD
well yeah, recently just tried my luck for my posting access to rising__sun@LJ and muahaha!
obviously, i failed~ :P wakakaka!
well, i knew it from the start anyway, their standards were super high~
they even rejected those that i thought were really good!
but anyway, they were the first 2 who gave constructive feedback to my amateur-ish icons...
and hmmmm, they kinda contradict with each other? lol!
i need more feedback actually, but seriously, i really dont know who to ask~
people just dont give constructive comments as they like :/
tell me what you think about this icons kay?
they are under the cut~
the two mods' comments (of rising__sun@LJ) are also under the cut!
by citharia:
Your first two icons were rather over-contrasted and over-sharpened, try playing around with curves and contrast/brightness to improve. The BoA icon is pretty well done, the coloring is soft and natural and shows a good grasp of cropping. Text style and placement, however, is awkward and text itself seems to serve little purpose.
by kawaiiheartt:
I thought your first icon was cropped very well, and the coloring was okay, if not a shade too red. Your second icon though stood out because it is very grainy and blurry, which gave it a more amateur and beginner feel. Your third icon was clear, and I liked the background. However, the text was a little too small, and didn't really balance out the cropping of the original image. While your signature had very nice effects done to it, the text again, was too small and blurry, making it a bit larger, or the entire graphic larger would help offset that.
yes, i knew that my text placement would kill~
留言列表